Cairngorms, Speyside Deer Management Group
Part 1 - Policy and Broad Objectives

This section introduces national policies and the legal background affecting land management in the area followed by the strategic directions currently being applied. Detailed information is provided on each of these in Appendix 3.

Individually, the Deer Commission for Scotland (DCS), Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH), Forestry Commission Scotland (FCS) and the Scottish Executive Environment & Rural Affairs Department (SEERAD) have different grant and regulatory powers which they use to promote and ensure sustainable management of grazing animals.

However, there are many circumstances where, used together, these powers can deliver more effective solutions. DCS, SNH, FCS and SEERAD are therefore combining efforts through Joint Working to better promote effective land management and protection of wider public interests. Joint Working between Agencies brings together the key mechanisms to enhance by use of targeted incentives, or if necessary, halt deterioration by regulatory action.

 
5.1 Cairngorms National Park

The CSDMG has adopted the aims of the National Park as they relate to the management of deer (Section 1). The National Park Authority seeks to ensure that the National Park aims are achieved in a co-ordinated way. In the context of these aims, natural heritage includes the flora and fauna of the NP, its geographical and physiographical features and its natural beauty and amenity.

 
5.2 EU legislation on protected areas and species
The ‘Habitats and Birds Directives’ present European Union legislation aimed at promoting the maintenance of biodiversity, taking account of economic, social, cultural and regional requirements.
 
5.3 UK Legislation on protected areas and species
The following UK legislation provides an important basis for developing nature conservation policy.
Conservation (Natural Habitats &c) Regulations 1994.
Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004.
Environmental Assessment of Plans and Programmes (Scotland) Regulations 2004.
 
5.4 Deer (Scotland) Act 1996
 
5.4.1 The Deer Commission for Scotland
The Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 established the Deer Commission for Scotland (DCS). The function of the DCS is to further the conservation, control and sustainable management of all species of wild deer in Scotland.

‘Damage’, as used throughout the Act, is interpreted as a ‘change of state that is regarded as detrimental to legitimate objectives’. Consequently, the assessment of damage is dependent on the legitimacy of the objectives in question and the seriousness of that damage as related to local circumstances

 
5.4.2 DCS Sites for Assessment and Priority Sites
DCS implement policy through a three-part process to identify sites where unacceptable damage is occurring and where there is a high priority for improved deer management. This will usually then become the subject of a management agreement (under Section 7 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996), with DCS, aimed at resolving the problem.
 
5.4.3 Deer Control Agreements
Under Section 7 of the Act, voluntary agreements can be made between DCS and owners/occupiers aimed at achieving the control of deer populations to meet local land use objectives. Section 8 of the Act provides DCS with statutory powers to establish Control Schemes that in turn enable the compulsory control of deer populations if required
 
5.5 The Cairngorms Local Biodiversity Action Plan
The current Cairngorms LBAP lists all species and habitats listed by the UK Biodiversity Action Plan Steering Group known to occur in the Cairngorms area. Distribution maps and information on the status, significance and population trends are provided. The CSDMG supports the objectives of the Cairngorms LBAP
 
5.6 Scottish Forestry Strategy
In the Scottish Forestry Strategy, published by the Scottish Executive, conservation is covered under one of five major Strategic Directions titled, ’To make a positive contribution to the environment’
 
5.7 Local Forestry Frameworks
The Cairngorms Forest and Woodland Framework provides a vehicle for delivering the National Park’s woodland objectives.
 
5.8 Estate Plans
Some estates have developed written plans covering aspects of estate management including Forest Plans, Biodiversity plans and Deer Management Plans. Some estates will use this DMP as their estate DMP
 
5.9 Natural Heritage Futures
Natural Heritage Futures (NHF) outline a contribution toward sustainable development published by Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH). The documents outlining NHF provide a vision for the sustainable management of Scotland’s landscapes to 2025.

Website: Ardchattan Solutions Ltd